Caring in America

With Podcast Host: Richard Wexler

Episode 116

Caregivers or Scaretakers?

A Hard Conversation We All Need to Have

For many caregivers, the journey doesn’t begin with a plan. It begins with a phone call.

In Episode 116 of Caring in America, Richard Wexler sits down with Jacklyn “Jacci” Ryan- self-described “reluctant expert” in senior advocacy- to unpack a story that is as painful as it is important. It’s a conversation about trust, vulnerability, and a system that too often fails the very people it’s meant to protect.

This is not an easy story. But it’s one families across America need to hear.


When One Fall Changes Everything

Jacci’s caregiving journey began the way so many do: one fall does it all.

Her father broke his hip, launching her into a caregiving world she was completely unprepared for- juggling work, family, and round-the-clock care. Over the next seven years, Jacci navigated home care agencies, hospice, and the emotional toll of caring for aging parents who were divorced and living separate realities.

Like many families in crisis, Jacci did what most of us would do: she hired the first home care agency she was referred to. There was no time to interview multiple providers. There was no roadmap. There was only urgency.

And that urgency would later come at a devastating cost.


The Caregiver Who Showed Up—and Stayed Too Long

Eventually, Jacci’s father required 24/7 care. After cycling through multiple caregivers, one finally seemed to fit. She showed up. She was on time. She was friendly, engaging, and her father liked her.

For a family worn down by constant turnover, that consistency felt like relief.

But six months into her employment, Jacci discovered a $900 receipt for new tires- tires purchased for the caregiver’s personal vehicle and paid for by her father.

That should have been the moment to act.

Instead, exhausted and desperate to avoid starting over again, the family kept her on.

Jacci calls it the biggest mistake of their lives.


Exploitation Disguised as “Care”

Over time, the situation worsened. The caregiver slowly isolated Jacci’s father, positioning herself as indispensable while discrediting other caregivers and family members.

Then came the revelation that changed everything: the caregiver had a criminal history, including time in jail for meth-related charges.

The home care agency knew.

Jacci didn’t.

Despite this knowledge, the agency kept the caregiver employed- because her father was a high-paying client, spending more than $220,000 a year on care.

This wasn’t just negligence. It was a system failure.

 


When Manipulation Becomes Emotional Abuse

As Jacci began questioning care logs and expenses, the caregiver escalated. She convinced Jacci’s father that his daughter was after his money and planned to put him in a nursing home.

Despite Jacci holding both financial and healthcare power of attorney, her father was persuaded to remove her as his healthcare POA- without a conversation, without warning.

From that moment on, Jacci’s relationship with her father was effectively severed.

He stopped calling. He stopped talking. He lived close enough to see her house- but remained emotionally unreachable.

This wasn’t just financial exploitation. It was emotional elder abuse.


The Silence Around Elder Abuse

One of the most troubling realities Jacci highlights is how rarely these stories are shared.

Families feel embarrassed. Ashamed. Afraid of retaliation. Or simply too exhausted to fight a system that feels stacked against them.

As Richard notes in the episode, there are thousands- likely millions- of similar stories playing out across the country every single day.

And most never see the light of day.


Turning Pain Into Advocacy

Instead of walking away, Jacci chose to act.

She authored the book Caregivers Scaretakers: Exposing Fraud in Senior Care, detailing her father’s story and others like it. She began working with the Alzheimer’s Association and state legislators in Arkansas to push for mandatory fingerprinting and background checks for caregivers.

While early legislative efforts stalled, Jacci isn’t giving up. She’s now running for county justice of the peace, advocating for:

  • Mandatory fingerprinting and background checks for caregivers

  • Ongoing, real-time background monitoring

  • Local elder abuse hotlines

  • Ultimately, federal protections for seniors receiving in-home care

Her message is simple: if we protect our children this way, why wouldn’t we protect our aging parents?


What Families Can Do Before a Crisis

Jacci leaves listeners with practical, hard-earned advice:

  • Don’t wait for a crisis. Interview at least three home care agencies before you need one.

  • Ask tough questions. What is their vetting process? Are caregivers fingerprinted? Background checked?

  • Trust your instincts. Consistency should never come at the cost of safety.

  • Speak up. Silence protects the wrong people.

Resources, including a caregiver vetting questionnaire, are available at www.caregiverscaretakers.com.


A Conversation That Matters

As Richard reminds us, more than 100 million Americans are over the age of 50—and most want to age at home. That reality makes this issue impossible to ignore.

This episode isn’t about fear. It’s about awareness, preparation, and protecting dignity.

Because caregiving should never become caretaking.

And because the people who once protected us deserve nothing less than the same care in return.


To connect with Jacci Ryan or learn more about her advocacy, visit www.caregiverscaretakers.com or email info@caregiverscaretakers.com.

With Special Guest: Jacklyn “Jacci” Ryan

Senior Care Advocate, Consultant, Speaker, and Author

Subscribe for updates

Enjoying our podcast? Subscribe to be notified of new episodes when they come out.

Our country is entering a new chapter, one we have never seen before… over 100 million people are 50 years of age or older, and the need for care is going to be more and more prevalent. We are dreaming of a nation where aging and care are understood and become part of our normal conversations with family.

To make this a reality, we need your help!

Contact

(925) 984-0118

info@aplan2age.org

Navigation

Resources

Donate